Circleville, Ohio. 1976. It started with strange gossip letters, targeting Mary Gillespie, accusing her of an affair. The letters continued, targeting others in this small, rural town, threatening lives and reputations. But when someone ended up dead, who was to blame?

Show Notes

Booby traps, car crashes, affairs, drama – it sounds like an overwrought soap opera, but this was real. Who was writing these letters? Was the death really “accidental” and was the accused writer really the culprit? Buckle up, ghouls. This one’s a real unsolved doozy.

References coming soon!